spinUP vs. Bruker E-580: Pulse EPR Benchmark Results
How does a modular pulse EPR spectrometer compare with an established commercial system? To answer this objectively, Spinflex measured the same standard sample on the spinUP and on a Bruker ELEXSYS E-580 pulsed spectrometer, comparing the two parameters that matter most in daily pulse EPR work: spin sensitivity and signal stability.
Test setup
- Sample: the standard Bruker DEER reference sample – a stable nitroxide biradical (DEER-Q, Bruker P.N. E3005327), in quartz tubes of 2/3 mm i.d./o.d. at X-band and 1.4/1.6 mm at Q-band.
- X-band: both systems measured the sample in the same Bruker MD4 resonator at room temperature, each with a similar 1 kW TWT amplifier.
- Q-band: the Bruker system used an EN 5107D2 resonator (2 mm sample access); spinUP-Q used a Spinflex dielectric resonator with 1.6 mm sample access.
Sensitivity: field-swept echo

| Parameter | Bruker E-580 | spinUP |
|---|---|---|
| π/2 / π pulse length (rect.) | 12 / 24 ns | 12 / 24 ns |
| Phase cycle | +/– on first pulse | +/– on first pulse |
| Interpulse delay τ | 120 ns | 250 ns |
| Scans × averages per scan | 16 × 10 | 1 × 160 |
| Shot repetition time | 2 ms | 2 ms |
| Noise bias (normalized) | 0.05 | 0.015 |
| Noise std (normalized) | 0.0034 | 0.0042 |
| Signal-to-noise ratio | 294 | 238 |
The measured signal-to-noise ratio of spinUP is slightly lower – but spinUP measured the echo at a longer interpulse delay (250 ns vs. 120 ns), where the room-temperature signal has already decayed by roughly 25–30%. Once this decay is taken into account, the sensitivity of the two systems is essentially the same. The noise DC bias of spinUP was also significantly lower than that of the Bruker system. Differences in spectral shape result from the way the field-swept echo data are processed.
Stability: DEER at Q-band
Stability is critical for double electron–electron resonance (DEER), where small changes in a large signal are followed as a function of the pulse timing. Both systems measured the same standard DEER sample at room temperature with the same total measurement time of about 30 minutes, using observer π/2 and π pulses of 20 and 40 ns and a 30 ns pump pulse (Gaussian pulses on spinUP).

Both systems gave comparable results. The Bruker system showed a slightly smaller modulation depth – possibly due to its larger resonator – even though spinUP-Q operated at lower microwave power (5 W vs. 10 W). Note that spinUP-Q detected the echo further from the pulses, which reveals more modulation but suffers more from T2 decay.
Conclusions
- spinUP delivers sensitivity comparable to a leading commercial X-band pulsed spectrometer under matched conditions.
- At Q-band, spinUP-Q produces DEER data of comparable quality at half the microwave power.
- Because spinUP is modular, these results are available both as a complete system and as an upgrade of an existing CW EPR spectrometer.
For structural-biology DEER work on a benchtop Q-band system, see also spinPRO. New to pulse EPR? Start with our Pulse EPR Spectrometer guide.
Bruker and ELEXSYS are trademarks of Bruker Corporation. Measurements were performed by Spinflex; results depend on sample, resonator and measurement parameters.